cran comments for release 0.8.0 (#4168)

* cran comments for release 0.8.0

* started to classify packages in terms of their problems with dplyr 0.8.0

* changes

* update [ci skip]

* also mention #4174 [ci skip]

* updates [ci skip]

* updates [ci skip]

* updates [ci skip]

cran-comments.md

@@ -1,21 +1,141 @@
 ## Release summary
 
-Minor update to address CRAN warnings and a conflict for an exported symbol.  We also addressed all rchk errors seen on CRAN but could not replicate them locally, it remains to be seen if our changes are effective.
+Fairly major update. We tried to limit the disruption as much as possible, 
+but this introduces a few breaking changes that are documented in the NEWS file. 
+
+Maintainers have been notified twice: a month ago and a week ago. 
+We confirmed that all changes were deliberate (either bug fixes or deliberate API changes) and provided guidance on how to update existing code
 
 ## Test environments
 
-* local OS X install, R 3.5.0
-* ubuntu 12.04 (on travis-ci), R 3.5.0, R-oldrel, R-devel.
+* local mac OS install, R 3.5.0
+* ubuntu 14.04 (on travis-ci), R-devel, R 3.5.2, R 3.4.4, R 3.3.3, R 3.2.5, R 3.1.3.
+* mac OS 10.3.3 (on travis-ci) R 3.5.2
 * win-builder (devel)
 
 ## R CMD check results
 
 0 ERRORs | 0 WARNINGs | 1 NOTE
 
-* checking installed package size ... NOTE
+*  checking installed package size ...
+     installed size is  6.3Mb
+     sub-directories of 1Mb or more:
+       R      2.1Mb
+       libs   2.4Mb
+
+## revdepcheck results
+
+We checked 1509 reverse dependencies (1379 from CRAN + 130 from BioConductor), comparing R CMD check results across CRAN and dev versions of this package.
+
+ * We saw 40 new problems
+ * We failed to check 46 packages
+
+Issues with CRAN packages are summarised below.
+
+### New problems
+(This reports the first line of each new failure)
+
+* alphavantager: API rate limit issue
+
+ * bupaR
+ * dplyr.teradata
+ * dtplyr
+ * tidygraph
+  S3 generic/method consistency: sample_n() gained ... 
+
+ * desctable
+  code/documentation mismatches ... group_by() gained .drop=
+
+ * zFactor
+ * visdat
+ * heemod: 
+ * naniar: Needs to import dplyr::n()
+
+ * cytominer: related to failures from dbplyr
+
+ * ggmap: NOTE, sub directory data/ > 1Mb
+
+ * portalr: test relies on digest()ing a data frame, probably related to changes in internals of grouped data frames
+
+ * postal: IO problem, probably unrelated
+
+ * purrrlyr: Work is being done in the dev version
+
+ * simTool: test uses internal format of grouped tibbles, which has changed. PR sent. 
+
+ * tibbletime: test problem. PR sent. 
+
+ * treeplyr: The package uses internal details. PR sent. 
+
+ * tsibble: Fixed in the dev version
+ * vqtl: Fixed in the dev version
+ * modeldb: Fixed in the dev version
+ * rPref: Fixed in the dev version
+ * ruler: Fixed in the dev version 
+ * dbplyr: fixed in dev version
+ * lmeresampler: Fixed in dev version
+ * ggfan: Fixed in dev version
+
+ * dexter: Fails to build the vignette, not sure why
+
+ * processcheckR: needs an update of the bupaR package
+ * edeaR: needs an update of the bupaR package
+
+ * ezsummary: Needs to use api instead of attributes. PR sent. 
+
+ * gravity: Does not correctly use tidyeval, PR sent. 
+
+ * poplite: Not sure what the problem is. 
+
+ * corrr: Not sure what the problem is. Issue sent. 
 
-  This is all compiled code in the libs/ directory.
+ * safetyGraphics: Should use `.` instead of `.data$.` PR sent. 
 
-## Reverse dependencies
+### Failed to check
 
-We checked more than 900 reverse dependencies by running R CMD check twice, once with the CRAN version installed, and once with this version installed. We did not see any new problems.
+* anomalyDetection   (failed to install)
+* arkdb              (check timed out)
+* bsam               (failed to install)
+* circumplex         (failed to install)
+* clustermq          (check timed out)
+* CollapsABEL        (failed to install)
+* colorednoise       (failed to install)
+* DepthProc          (failed to install)
+* DiversityOccupancy (failed to install)
+* dynfrail           (failed to install)
+* easyformatr        (failed to install)
+* fastLink           (failed to install)
+* FSelectorRcpp      (failed to install)
+* graphicalVAR       (failed to install)
+* harrietr           (failed to install)
+* heatwaveR          (failed to install)
+* HTSSIP             (check timed out)
+* idefix             (failed to install)
+* ijtiff             (failed to install)
+* iRF                (failed to install)
+* lilikoi            (failed to install)
+* LLSR               (failed to install)
+* lpirfs             (failed to install)
+* mapfuser           (failed to install)
+* mbgraphic          (failed to install)
+* miceFast           (failed to install)
+* MonetDBLite        (check timed out)
+* morse              (failed to install)
+* petro.One          (failed to install)
+* phase1PRMD         (failed to install)
+* pmc                (check timed out)
+* poppr              (failed to install)
+* qdap               (failed to install)
+* Rdrools            (failed to install)
+* rmcfs              (failed to install)
+* rpcdsearch         (failed to install)
+* RtutoR             (failed to install)
+* segclust2d         (failed to install)
+* sf                 (failed to install)
+* simputation        (failed to install)
+* textmining         (failed to install)
+* vapour             (failed to install)
+* vlad               (failed to install)
+* wand               (failed to install)
+* weibulltools       (failed to install)
+* windfarmGA         (failed to install)