You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
As the developer of a radio webcast management tool, I have been asked by multiple users to implement support for the main branch of Icecast, as opposed to the current support my application has for a custom compiled copy of Icecast-KH.
One of the largest obstacles to switching back to the main Icecast branch is the fact that there exist a number of radio licensing services that offer to proxy a radio connection through their servers, track the traffic and ensure royalties are paid accordingly. Because the traffic arriving at Icecast's doorstep appears to all be from the same IP, however, it's impossible to distinguish the actual listeners in question or their geographic areas.
Karl Heyes had adopted a somewhat novel solution to this problem: specifying a whitelist of IPs that are allowed to send the X-Forwarded-For header as part of their traffic. If the inbound listener has this header and is being proxied from a whitelisted IP, the internally referenced IP is updated to the forwarded address instead, allowing for proper metrics and tracking. Unfortunately, a limitation of this approach is that every IP that will send the header must be known ahead of time, which is impossible if IPs are dynamically assigned (a-la Docker containers) from a broad pool.
If this feature or some facsimile of it were implemented on the main Icecast branch (alongside the SSL improvements that enable LetsEncrypt, see ticket #20) it would far and away be the key to ensuring that several radio services feel comfortable making the switch back to the main branch.
I'm not sure that this Github Issues section is heavily used by the Icecast dev team, but hopefully the feedback gets into the right hands. Thank you for your time!
Edit: It appears I was blocked from Xiph's GitLab entirely, and my account deleted, for having submitted this request. I don't understand the rationale behind that decision at all, as I have been quite civil and appreciative of the work done by Icecast maintainers. I am a FOSS maintainer myself and the work I produce is entirely free to the public and non-commercial in nature, licensed under the AGPL. This decision confuses and upsets me greatly.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
As the developer of a radio webcast management tool, I have been asked by multiple users to implement support for the main branch of Icecast, as opposed to the current support my application has for a custom compiled copy of Icecast-KH.
One of the largest obstacles to switching back to the main Icecast branch is the fact that there exist a number of radio licensing services that offer to proxy a radio connection through their servers, track the traffic and ensure royalties are paid accordingly. Because the traffic arriving at Icecast's doorstep appears to all be from the same IP, however, it's impossible to distinguish the actual listeners in question or their geographic areas.
Karl Heyes had adopted a somewhat novel solution to this problem: specifying a whitelist of IPs that are allowed to send the
X-Forwarded-For
header as part of their traffic. If the inbound listener has this header and is being proxied from a whitelisted IP, the internally referenced IP is updated to the forwarded address instead, allowing for proper metrics and tracking. Unfortunately, a limitation of this approach is that every IP that will send the header must be known ahead of time, which is impossible if IPs are dynamically assigned (a-la Docker containers) from a broad pool.If this feature or some facsimile of it were implemented on the main Icecast branch (alongside the SSL improvements that enable LetsEncrypt, see ticket #20) it would far and away be the key to ensuring that several radio services feel comfortable making the switch back to the main branch.
I'm not sure that this Github Issues section is heavily used by the Icecast dev team, but hopefully the feedback gets into the right hands. Thank you for your time!
Edit: It appears I was blocked from Xiph's GitLab entirely, and my account deleted, for having submitted this request. I don't understand the rationale behind that decision at all, as I have been quite civil and appreciative of the work done by Icecast maintainers. I am a FOSS maintainer myself and the work I produce is entirely free to the public and non-commercial in nature, licensed under the AGPL. This decision confuses and upsets me greatly.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: