-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 39
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
IC4 / Garmin wrong power output #98
Comments
Do you feel the resistance change in your legs when you encounter this issue? I am sure you are as going from ~150W to ~220W is quite a bit. If you don't feel the resistance change in your legs, I am wondering if this has to do with the mechanical part of the dial or perhaps the IC4 bike itself is reporting incorrect power? I think Gymnasticon works on just retransmitting the values spit out by the bike's computer and doesn't alter them unless you put the power-scale factors in the config file. I don't know how IC4 bike works, but I am guessing it is similar to the Flywheel spin bike I have. On mine, the resistance is changed using a dial which is tied to a cable to change the resistance while riding. Sometimes that cable gets stuck in the housing or doesn't release/pull all the way when I make small changes to the dial (like going from 40 to 42). If this happens I just make larger changes on the dial until I see desired power on my Garmin head unit (It usually overshoots and I have to dial it back tho). If you suspect that it is a mechanical issue, have you tried changing the resistance to a higher value to see if your issue persists? |
The mechanical resistance is definitely there! I can feel it 😄 There is something like a red faucet that you spin in one direction or the other, which changes the difficulty (the distance of magnetic elements around the metallic wheel that make it change the resistance). This is definitely not a problem in the bike for two reasons:
I also eliminated Garmin as the source of error by trying another Garmin device. My thought process was that maybe Gymnasticon reports correct data, but Garmin screws it up somehow and only starts reporting when re-connected back to Gymnasticon. |
I can try pulling the whole log for the whole half an hour training if it helps somehow... |
So I managed to log the time where the issue happened. I was doing my interval at about 56 difficulty level and then went down to difficulty 36, which should result the power dropping from 220 to 150-160. However, my Garmin was still showing power about 220. Interestingly, in the logs the power drop is logged correctly from 220 to 150 and then to 110:
Not sure if that is a Garmin issue after all. Tried both Fenix 6 and 7 and both have shown this behaviour. Restarting RPi (hence, reconnecting Garmin) fixes the problem. What I can test next time is re-connecting the Garmin sensors in the settings without restarting RPi and see if that fixes the issue. Then it would be an indication on Garmin side. |
Don’t have an ic4, but do use gymnasticon with keiser and fenix 6 and never had anything like that, Have you tried just writing another sd card with the software just in case it’s that simple an issue?? Or moving ant closer to watch to reduce interference? I believe Chris Elsen on here uses it with an ic4/bowflex c6 which are supposedly all same/similar - if there had been an issue he would have seen and highlighted it I’m sure. |
Sorry for the stupid question, but I use IC8 since one year (IC4/IC8 mostly the same with little difference in details like power cord and a few esthetic things). Asking just for curiosity to understand other pattern usage. |
Connect to other devices using ant+ eg zwift on laptop or a Garmin bike computer or smart watch?? |
So I have the gymnasticon running with ANT+ on a RPi Zero W, connecting to IC4.
IC4 has difficulty levels from 1-100. When I start pedalling at 32 difficulty, the reported power is about 140-160, which is fine. But when I start doing 3-minute intervals, where I switch the difficulty between 32 and 55, at some point gymnasticon reports pervious power as if I did not change the difficulty.
That is, if I pedal for 3 minutes at 32 the reported power is 140-160. Then I change the power to 55, but the reported power stays at 140-160 (should be 200-230). During half an hour of training, I need to restart the RPi once. Then the power is reported correctly again. This is not happening each time. On average, once every half an hour from what I have seen so far.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: