For the following 3 tables the poll request is sent every 15ms. The experiments were ran in docker on a computer running a 2.6 GHz 6-Core Intel Core i7 processor with 16 GB 2667 MHz DDR4 memory.
The following time data was collected for a simulation of 60 simulated seconds and with the debug print statements active
| topology tested | IEEE model | Number of Nodes | Number of Paths | Attack? | Time (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4G LTE | 9500 | 45 | 121 | No attacks | 34369.21 |
| 4G LTE | 9500 | 45 | 121 | DDoS with 2 attackers | 41737.71 |
| 4G LTE | 9500 | 45 | 121 | MIM with 2 attacker | 35085.39 |
| 4G LTE | 123 | 17 | 16 | No attack | 4372.48 |
| 4G LTE | 123 | 17 | 16 | DDoS with 1 attackers | 14684.11 |
| 4G LTE | 123 | 17 | 16 | MIM with 3 attackers | 5796.20 |
The following data is the same amount of simulated seconds but with no print lines but data collection is still active
| topology tested | IEEE model | Number of Nodes | Number of Paths | Attack? | Time (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | no attack | 28885.06 |
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | DDoS with 2 attacker | 85648.90 |
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | MIM with 2 attackers | 30580.91 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | no attack | 5824.01 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | DDoS with 1 attacker | 17698.04 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | MIM with 3 attackers | 5351.68 |
| 4G LTE | 9500 | 45 | 121 | no attacker | 30048.81 |
| 4G LTE | 9500 | 45 | 121 | DDoS with 2 attackers | 24697.42 |
| 4G LTE | 9500 | 45 | 121 | MIM with 2 attackers | 36660.07 |
| 4G LTE | 123 | 17 | 16 | no attack | 4868.21 |
| 4G LTE | 123 | 17 | 16 | DDoS with 1 attacker | 19900.36 |
| 4G LTE | 123 | 17 | 16 | MIM with 3 attackers | 2794.67 |
| (3G) Mesh | 9500 | 23 | 121 | no attack | 17616.97 |
| (3G) Mesh | 9500 | 23 | 121 | DDoS with 1 attacker | 17339.23 |
| (3G) Mesh | 9500 | 23 | 121 | MIM 2 attackers | 15537.93 |
| (3G) Mesh | 123 | 9 | 16 | no attack | 2106.03 |
| (3G) Mesh | 123 | 9 | 16 | DDoS with 1 attacker | 4196.78 |
| (3G) Mesh | 123 | 9 | 16 | MIM with 3 attackers | 2121.83 |
| (3G) Star | 9500 | 23 | 11 | no attack | 6018.12 |
| (3G) Star | 9500 | 23 | 11 | DDoS with 2 attackers | 8914.86 |
| (3G) Star | 9500 | 23 | 11 | MIM with 2 attackers | 6815.02 |
| (3G) Star | 123 | 9 | 4 | no attack | 1428.09 |
| (3G) Star | 123 | 9 | 4 | DDoS with 1 attacker | 3879.00 |
| (3G) Star | 123 | 9 | 4 | MIM with 3 attackers | 1415.56 |
The following data is the same amount of simulated seconds but with no print statement or data collection
| topology tested | IEEE model | Number of Nodes | Number of Paths | Attack? | Time (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | no attack | 45732.18 |
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | DDoS with 2 attackers | 74192.72 |
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | MIM with 2 attackers | 31666.34 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | no attack | 5795.19 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | DDoS with 1 attacker | 10591.63 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | MIM with 3 attackers | 7997.78 |
| 4G LTE | 9500 | 45 | 121 | no attack | 26244.69 |
| 4G LTE | 9500 | 45 | 121 | DDoS with 2 attackers | 36607.44 |
| 4G LTE | 9500 | 45 | 121 | MIM with 2 attackers | 24107.69 |
| 4G LTE | 123 | 17 | 16 | no attack | 4098.09 |
| 4G LTE | 123 | 17 | 16 | DDoS with 1 attacker | 8354.13 |
| 4G LTE | 123 | 17 | 16 | MIM with 3 attackers | 2683.45 |
| (3G) Mesh | 9500 | 23 | 121 | no attack | 17391.63 |
| (3G) Mesh | 9500 | 23 | 121 | DDoS with 1 attackers | 19135.84 |
| (3G) Mesh | 9500 | 23 | 121 | MIM with 2 attackers | 15076.19 |
| (3G) Mesh | 123 | 9 | 16 | no attack | 2385.79 |
| (3G) Mesh | 123 | 9 | 16 | DDoS with 1 attacker | 4152.84 |
| (3G) Mesh | 123 | 9 | 16 | MIM with 3 attackers | 1986.06 |
| (3G) Star | 9500 | 23 | 11 | no attack | 6435.05 |
| (3G) Star | 9500 | 23 | 11 | DDoS with 2 attackers | 7879.37 |
| (3G) Star | 9500 | 23 | 11 | MIM with 2 attacker | 6879.18 |
| (3G) Star | 123 | 9 | 4 | no attack | 1844.98 |
| (3G) Star | 123 | 9 | 4 | DDoS with 1 attacker | 3861.15 |
| (3G) Star | 123 | 9 | 4 | MIM with 3 attacker | 1560.43 |
The following 5G run was run with 2X higher bandwidth. We went from sending a packet every 15 ms to every 7ms
| topology tested | IEEE model | Number of Nodes | Number of Paths | Attack? | Data collection? | Time (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | no attack | yes | 8460.03 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | DDoS with 1 attacker | yes | 19895.78 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | MIM with 3 attacker | yes | 5715.21 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | no attack | no | 4321.34 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | DDoS with 1 attacker | no | 8121.72 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | MIM with 3 attackers | no | 7420.40 |
Running the 5G example with the IEEE 9500 bus model and debug statements activated on a shared computing system using slurm
| topology tested | IEEE model | Number of Nodes | Number of Paths | Attack? | Time (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | no attack | 6736.61 |
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | DDoS with 2 attackers | 8269.92 |
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | MIM with 2 attackers | 7376.86 |
Running the 5G example with the 9500 bus model and the debug statements turned off and the data collection still running on a shared computing system using slurm
| topology tested | IEEE model | Number of Nodes | Number of Paths | Attack? | Time (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | no attack | 7077.42 |
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | DDoS with 2 attackers | 8309.60 |
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | MIM with 2 attackers | 7381.56 |
Running the 5G example with the 9500 bus model and the debug statements turned off and the data collection in turned off on a shared computing system using slurm
| topology tested | IEEE model | Number of Nodes | Number of Paths | Attack? | Time (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | no attack | 7026.49 |
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | DDoS with 2 attackers | 8320.26 |
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | MIM with 2 attackers | 8143.94 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | no attack | 2359.56 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | DDoS 1 attacker | 3224.56 |
| 5G | 123 | 17 | 16 | MIM with 3 attackers | 2428.57 |
| 4G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | no attack | 3989.23 |
| 4G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | DDoS 2 attackers | 4205.97 |
| 4G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | MIM with 3 attackers | 5670.66 |
| 4G | 123 | 17 | 16 | no attack | 2234.71 |
| 4G | 123 | 17 | 16 | DDoS 1 attacker | 5349.98 |
| 4G | 123 | 17 | 16 | MIM with 3 attackers | 2293.31 |
| (3G) Mesh | 9500 | 45 | 121 | no attack | 4365.11 |
| (3G) Mesh | 9500 | 45 | 121 | DDoS 2 attacker | 4810.54 |
| (3G) Mesh | 9500 | 45 | 121 | MIM 2 attackers | 4329.21 |
| (3G) Mesh | 123 | 17 | 16 | no attack | 1995.36 |
| (3G) Mesh | 123 | 17 | 16 | DDoS 1 attackers | 2312.78 |
| (3G) Mesh | 123 | 17 | 16 | MIM with 3 attackers | 2101.10 |
| (3G) Star | 9500 | 45 | 121 | no attack | 3973.83 |
| (3G) Star | 9500 | 45 | 121 | DDoS 2 attacker | 4849.28 |
| (3G) Star | 9500 | 45 | 121 | MIM 2 attackers | 4386.04 |
| (3G) Star | 123 | 17 | 16 | no attack | 1944.87 |
| (3G) Star | 123 | 17 | 16 | DDoS 1 attacker | 2122.58 |
| (3G) Star | 123 | 17 | 16 | MIM 3 attackers | 1973.11 |
Running the 4G example on slurm with the data collection set to on. | 4G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | no attack | 4789.57 | | 4G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | DDoS 2 attackers | 5398.60 | | 4G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | MIM with 2 attackers | 9341.19 |
Running the 5G example with the 9500 bus model and the debug statements turned off and the data collection in turned off on a shared computing system using slurm with the poll request rate increased from every 15ms to every 7ms
| topology tested | IEEE model | Number of Nodes | Number of Paths | Attack? | Time (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | no attack | 11679.67 |
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | DDoS with 2 attackers | 13187.88 |
| 5G | 9500 | 45 | 121 | MIM with 2 attackers | 13738.76 |