Print profile is "Not supported", cant create custom profiles or edit new ones

[hitech95]

Application version
4.8.0

Platform
Windows 10 2004
i7-4790k, GTX1060

Printer
Ender 3 Pro

Reproduction steps

1. Install Cura
2. Select the printer in the Setup wizard
3. Create a new Material or use "PLA+" from eSUN. This happends on a lot non default Material.
4. Try to create a print profile.

Screenshot(s)

Actual results
Print Profile settings are grayed out, cannot store a custom profile.
Default profiles cannot be selected.

Expected results
Beeing able to create a custom priofile is the default one are not available.

Project file
Not needed, this happend even without any file open

Log file
cura.log

Additional information
Other people are facing the same issue.
https://community.ultimaker.com/topic/33336-non-generic-material-selection-causes-profiles-to-show-not-supported/

[fvrmr]

Did you change some print settings (like layer height) before you tried to create a profile?
Because after this you can create a profile even though it is not supported.

[Zer025]

I have the same problem: when creating a new material, if Material Type is PLA+ (or Nylon, PC, PVA and many others), Cura gives error "Not Supported". To workaround this problem I just used PLA instead of PLA+
I have Cura 4.12.0

[Ghostkeeper]

For clarity, the problem reported here is NOT that the print profile is "Not Supported". That part is correct and expected. The problem is that the user is not able to then create custom profiles.

We haven't been able to reproduce that issue so far. I hope we can get some clarity on how to reproduce that.

[hitech95]

For clarity, the problem reported here is NOT that the print profile is "Not Supported". That part is correct and expected. The problem is that the user is not able to then create custom profiles.

We haven't been able to reproduce that issue so far. I hope we can get some clarity on how to reproduce that.

Unfortunalty I'm not able to replicate the issue. I must have re installed cura in meanwhile.

What is that ""Not Supported" means!?

[Ghostkeeper]

Basically, it means that Cura has no profiles for the combination(s) printer+nozzle+material-type you're using. Instead it will use the default for that combination. It's probably not well optimised.

A related issue is #8229, which started out similar to this one but is currently about the unclarity of making profiles depend on the material type.

[GregValiant]

Is this still an issue in current Cura versions (5.8.0 and up)? Can this be closed?